The Answer Is the Cloud – Now What’s the Question?
Cloud Computing represents the new way for businesses to re-connect with their customers
By: Richard Stone
Sep. 13, 2010 07:15 AM
In Lewis Carroll's classic story "Through the Looking Glass," Humpty Dumpty remarked: "When I use a word, it means just what I choose it to mean - neither more nor less." It seems that the same principle applies to almost any industry expert and IT vendor when they talk about Cloud Computing. So, in an effort not to fall into the same trap as Humpty Dumpty, let's start with the obvious first question:
What exactly is Cloud Computing?
What's driving Cloud Computing today?
So when businesses turn their attention from survival mode to growth mode, they quickly realize that "reconnecting with the customer" is not a return to business as usual, but something that requires a complete rethink of the way they work, both externally and internally.
The new business imperatives for customer interaction are agility to meet rapidly changing market conditions, flexibility in the way that they do business and rapid time-to-value as trends are increasingly measured in days and weeks - not months and years. Inside organizations, new tools and business processes are needed to manage new ways to create demand, manage new distribution channels, communicate value to customers and provide visibility on rapidly changing customer trends.
Given the huge amount of publicity, it is inevitable that the CEO will hear or read the pitch that "Cloud provides agility, flexibility, and quicker time-to-value," and get hooked. What's keeping them awake at night is the need for a fundamental change in the way that they interact with customers, and the answer is right there in front of them - Cloud Computing. It's exactly what they need to immediately start challenging the IT department to develop a cloud strategy. As proof of this, a recent survey conducted by the 451 Group in June 2010 confirms that it is CEOs, not CIOs, who are driving Cloud Computing initiatives in most organizations.
The answer to the question - what's driving cloud computing - is very clear: Business Needs. Led by the CEO, the primary driver of cloud computing inside most organizations today is the line of business, where it's seen as an essential component of a "return to growth" strategy. Reducing cost, the primary focus for the last few years, is still important, but it's no longer one of the top priority items in an increasing number of company budgets today.
What does this mean to IT?
For most businesses, this process is a frustrating "take it or leave it" approach driven by IT, executed at IT's pace, and riddled with delays and cost overruns. What's more, it's completely inconsistent with the customer-facing and internally facing imperatives that the CEO and business leaders are now grappling with, in a fashion that IT cannot continue to operate in.
Cloud Computing offers a compelling alternative to the old way of providing IT services. Instead of internally developed monolithic systems, with lengthy and costly implementations of customized third-party business solutions, Cloud Computing provides an agile and flexible environment with shorter solution implementation cycles at a much lower cost. It represents a fundamental shift in the way that enterprises acquire and implement new IT functionality (computing power, storage, software, etc.) to support customer and organizational needs. In short, Cloud Computing offers IT a new way of implementing the functionality that the business units are demanding, and at a speed and cost that meets their expectations.
What this means to IT is that they are facing a critical choice that has to be made soon - either "Do nothing" or "Lead from the front." If they do nothing, business units have a choice now and they'll turn to any of the hundreds of SaaS vendors that can deliver 95 percent of the new functionality they need. These "fly under the corporate IT radar" solutions can be delivered as fast as it takes them to enter their credit card information, so they can have a great Salesforce Automation solution today with no commitment, no delay, and no IT.
"Leading from the front" is the only right course. IT owns IT, regardless of whether it comes from inside or outside the organization. Along with delivering completely new applications to the business, Cloud Computing will allow IT to enhance the functionality of existing applications by leveraging content and services from third-party providers. These "borderless" applications offer a best-of-both-worlds approach - the existing investments in legacy applications and the "systems of record" are protected, and new functionality to meet new needs can be delivered quickly and at a low initial cost.
What are the risks, and how can IT mitigate them?
The bottom line is that IT has to meet the business' expectation of faster delivery of new functionality and good performance, while at the same time addressing two key risks: ensuring that sensitive data remains protected in compliance with company policy and state/federal legislation; and maintaining end-to-end visibility and control of service performance and availability of borderless applications.
Performance and Availability
Recent experience by companies who have actually implemented cloud solutions paints an interesting picture of where IT should be focusing its risk mitigation efforts to ensure that cloud delivers real business benefits. Prior to implementation, many IT departments were unconvinced that Cloud Computing would deliver the promised business agility and flexibility benefits, and believed that the big win would be cost savings. They also believed that security concerns would tower above everything else as the number one unresolved problem, and that application performance and service level management problems would be solved by simply extending the capabilities of their existing APM solutions. Practical experience was quite different. Agility and flexibility turned out to be the number one win by a long shot; and performance and availability turned out to be tough problems that couldn't be effectively solved with their existing or planned APM solutions.
What's so hard about managing performance in the cloud?
From an end-user perspective, poor performance or non-availability of an application looks exactly the same, regardless of where the problem actually is in the application delivery chain - one of the service providers, in the data center, across the network, in the enterprise, in the cloud or with the end user's own device - and has exactly the same productivity impact to the business. For example, a mortgage loan pre-approval application that utilizes cloud-based services, what happens if one of the services performs badly or is not available at all? How can the enterprise determine if it's a service provider problem, a network problem or an end-user device problem?
To further complicate things, geographic location can also have a dramatic impact on the overall performance of a cloud-based application - this is somewhat contrary to the popular belief that Internet communication is virtually instantaneous. A worse-case scenario is that "all lights are green" in the data center, but some (not all) customers are complaining about performance issues. Without detailed fault-domain information across the entire delivery chain, it is virtually impossible to isolate and fix performance and availability issues in a timely manner, before they start to impact users.
CloudSleuth Web Portal: The Compuware-sponsored CloudSleuth community web portal is designed to meet the growing need for authoritative, objective measurements of cloud service providers. It provides free access to real-time performance and availability visualizations of leading cloud providers around the world, plus other valuable data such as blogs, forums and white papers - all focused on best practices for building, deploying, and managing cloud-based applications.
To illustrate how all the components of the delivery chain can impact performance of a web-based application, Figures 5 and 6 show actual measurements from CloudSleuth, a Compuware-sponsored web portal that provides real-time visualizations of the performance and availability of cloud service providers. CloudSleuth measures performance of a simple application (no I/O- or CPU-intensive tasks) deployed anonymously at a number of cloud services providers. The Gomez Performance Network is then used to access those applications from backbone and "Last Mile" locations around the world to provide actual performance results. All the tests below use only Amazon EC2 East and West.
"Figure 5: Last Mile" Internet Service Provider (ISP) Performance: This test shows how the response time is impacted by the performance of the user's ISP (the so-called "last mile" connection).
Note that users in Wyoming are experiencing performance issues because of "last mile" connectivity problems, not because of Amazon.
Figure 6: Geography: The graphs clearly show that the farther away the user is from the application, the longer the response time.
This test also illustrates that if enterprises have a choice of service providers, it is best to choose one that is nearest to their user and/or customer base.
Figure 7: Time of Day: This test shows that the performance of cloud service providers is not constant, but can vary quite widely throughout the day. This is generally because the service provider is handling a varying load from other users on their systems.
Figure 7 also illustrates another practical point about cloud performance: The cloud theoretically provides "rapid elasticity," meaning that wide variations in load can be accommodated without significantly impacting the performance of individual applications. In reality, cloud service providers have to live by the same rules of economics as everyone else - they do not have banks of servers lying idle to cope with these peaks in demand. Although applications operate in their own "instances" at the service provider, their performance is affected by what their neighbors are doing!
Conclusion - Putting It All Together
A key concern is managing the end-user experience of cloud-based applications by maintain complete visibility of the performance of these new borderless applications. Fred Smith, the founder of FedEx, once remarked: "Information about the package is as important as the package itself." He was making the case that it's not enough to provide a general statement of service quality; you must be able to present information on the particular service you are delivering to a particular customer at a particular time, regardless of where the package is. The same is true for borderless applications - these require a solution that can monitor and manage application performance regardless of physical, virtual or cloud attributes.
Traditional enterprise application performance management tools are unsuited to the task of managing this new generation of applications, because they only provide narrow, technology-centric keyhole views into the performance of specific components or processes. The only way to truly solve performance and availability problems is through a holistic view of application performance that encompasses the entire application delivery chain.
Reader Feedback: Page 1 of 1
Latest Cloud Developer Stories
Subscribe to the World's Most Powerful Newsletters
Subscribe to Our Rss Feeds & Get Your SYS-CON News Live!
SYS-CON Featured Whitepapers
Most Read This Week