News
Contrary Opinion: "The Internet Changes Nothing"
Contrary Opinion: "The Internet Changes Nothing"
Sep. 27, 2004 12:00 AM
Related Links:
i-Technology Viewpoint: SUNset?
Comdex Bites the Vegas Dust
Four years into waiting for Godot, I mean, waiting for the tech recovery, an unorthodox thought creeps into the corners of my enquiring mind. What if the Internet, rather than changing "everything" (as cited and recited in a well-known Silicon Valley quote), in fact changes nothing?
There's still plenty of suffering in the world. Plenty of existential angst for those lucky enough not to suffer physically. Traffic still seems pretty bad to me, everywhere. The phone at home still rings too much. In fact, today I'm surrounded by phones that beep, play music, and seemingly gandydance around the clock.
Gasoline is too expensive, as is insurance of all kinds, educational standards are going to hell, political discourse is still largely divisive and asinine, wind chills and high humidity remain popular topics of conversation, and my teen-age kids are driving me nuts.
The earth still rotates precessionally on its axis, the moon is reliable in its phases, the sun does indeed come up in the east every morning.
Ballplayers and entertainers are still way overpaid. There's too much gossip, too many dogs and cats, and maybe too many people. Business scandals pique our outrage. Crime is back up. The government is intruding, again.
Fear in the air, tension everywhere.
Segregation, determination, demonstration, integration. Aggravation, humiliation, obligation to our nation. Seems like the same old ball of confusion to me. How has the Internet changed anything?
The temptation is to trivialize progress made since the time of that late 60s hit song. Nothing's changed, man. Yet the band plays on, man.
Verily I won't go biblical and scare the kids with any new insights under the sun, because I don't have any. The point is to remember that the fundamentals never change. People are people, a relativistic universe means there's no such thing as a sure thing, the walk is the walk and the hype is the hype, and the U.S. remains the only place where the pursuit of happiness is enshrined in its founding document.
Thank-you, everyone for developing, deploying, and improving the Internet. Thank-you Tim Berners-Lee for realizing its power. But no thanks to everyone who has overemphasized it, paradigmatically hyperbolized it, obtusely not gotten that it doesn't matter if you don't get it, what matters is that it doesn't fundamentally change a thing.
All it has really done over the past decade is pumped up a false New Economy then become a victim of its own press releases while hurling millions of dreams onto the cruel and rocky shores of a place known as Brutal Realityland.
The Internet is just a tool. Just another addiction to some, just another exploited medium to exploit to others, and a darn fine way to communicate to most.
Well, yes, actually it provides a great way to communicate, you know, whether by e-mail, Web site, or blog. It's an Alexandrine repository of knowledge, and its shopping mall aspect has kept me out of hot water on more than one Mother's Day. Hmm, maybe it could change things if we gave it a try. Maybe it already has. It's affected thinking, strategies, and processes throughout the business world. It's made many governments more transparent to their citizens, and put other governments on notice that the democracy genie is out of the bottle. It's empowering a truly global community to create and share knowledge inexpensively, quickly, and effectively.
OK then, maybe the Internet is playing a large role in changing things for the better, and will continue to do so. But no way, no how will it ever "change everything." Let's extinguish vacuous phrases such as that from our public utterings and collective consciousness, please?
Related Links:
i-Technology Viewpoint: SUNset?
Comdex Bites the Vegas Dust
About Roger StrukhoffRoger Strukhoff holds a BA from Knox College, Certificate in Technical Communications from UC-Berkeley, and MBA from CSU-Hayward. He won a 2009 "Stevie" American Business Award for producing the best publication in its category. He is a former Publisher at IDG and Guest Lecturer at MIT. He splits most of his time between Silicon Valley and Southeast Asia, but can also be found at
www.twitter.com/strukhoff
#9 |
Joe D commented on 29 Sep 2004
And yet...what is it that needs to be changed? I forgot.
|
#8 |
Joe D commented on 29 Sep 2004
Not only does the internet changes nothing. Technology itself does not change anything.
We are just mere seconds in a one minute clock reaching the first second...backwards.
|
#7 |
UniversalIntelligence commented on 29 Sep 2004
<>
<>
That's telling em! Yup, sorry, you were born into a very strict universe that operates on certain basic un-alterable principles. When it rains you get wet, when the sun shines you get hot, grass is green - all of these things work.
The internet is junk food for so-called techies. It was based on weak infrastructure and is supported by the most ridiculous of script languages. What exactly did you expect?!
|
#6 |
Hal commented on 28 Sep 2004
Unfortunately, any technology can be used for both good and bad, and the internet has been able to reach into those areas of human inventiveness which showcase both the human mind at its best and at its very worst. It's unlikely any other technology has been able to reach as far into the cultural and societal fabric of humanity as quickly and pervasively.
Among the worst users of the internet are the the vermin who send us viruses, pop-ups, spam email, phishing attempts to sucker us out of our money and other intrusions into our efforts to use it productively, to promote the human (or our employer's) cause.
Among the best are those who care and inform and voice their concern for our world, its peoples, the millions of disadvantaged and dying and the billions of creatures which inhabit this fragile planet with us give rise to web sites which inform us, lift us up, stimulate us to take action, get out of our chairs and actually make a difference somewhere, to something.
The good of the internet is it permits people to look things up and make connections between items of information, and connect to other people and other groups faster than any previous generation has been able to do. Some of this information is truthful and useful, some false and malevolent, some (like kiddie porn) truly presents an element of humanity at its very worst and most depraved. Hopefully we will be able to more quickly develop the means and wisdom to discern the one from the other.
By itself, the internet likely can't change anything - it's only people, sometimes through using the internet as leverage, who can make change. The internet is like information for its own sake - inert and of academic interest. Information plus Action plus Wisdom plus Heart can lead to growth and a positive future, but the Internet can only feed one fourth of that equation. The rest of it lies within us, always has.
Let's not be too enamoured of our technology - smart as some of it's becoming, at best it's there to help us become more Human, and hopefully more Humane some day.
An artificial heart may pump well and save a life, but it can't feel.
|
#5 |
Jeff G commented on 28 Sep 2004
Well, the Web does help when one encounters a new word like gandydance. Pre-web, I would have to had gotten up and gone to look for a dictionary to find its meaning. And I probably would have been too lazy to do that.
But sitting at my computer, I could ck it at two dictionary web sites (neither had it!) and then utilize a search engine to find it is extremely rare in usage! Aside from your blog, there were just a few other citations, with the meaning to work on railroad tracks which does not seem to fit your context. And lo and behold there is one book with Gandydance in the title! And it is the story of a railroad worker!
However at one time there was even a web site www.gandydance.com although it does not exist now.
So my curiosity got more piqued. So please--where did you get this word and how?
|
#4 |
To assess the overall impact of the internet on our world economy, you should step back and take in a broader view of the past century. If you have broadband, I highly recommend you watch Commanding Heights, a video presentation that PBS has graciously made available online: http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/commandingheights/hi/story/
Good stuff. And it'll really put the effect of the internet in proper historical perspective. (Spoiler: Yes, the internet is very important).
|
#3 |
enydonae commented on 28 Sep 2004
Yessir, Mr. Strukhoff, you're really onto something here. The Internet is just like a new baby or a new religion or a new war: for some people, it really does change everything; for the rest, ho hum. There are Sumerian inscriptions from 4000 BC lamenting that the younger generation is destroying civilization. We're all just chimpanzees with tools and language anyway: we use language to express our chimpanzee desires and tools to attain them. Banana? Oook! Oook! Eeep! Eeep!
|
#2 |
fu darling commented on 28 Sep 2004
Wow, no one pulls anything over on you middle class crackers.
|
#1 |
tim commented on 28 Sep 2004
Sounds like you need a holiday. Have you tried Australia?
|